Use of Artificial Intelligence (AI) Guideline
Use of Artificial Intelligence (AI)
Principles
BHJ permits the responsible use of AI-assisted technologies in preparing manuscripts, provided that human authors remain accountable for the work and that significant use is transparently disclosed. Disclosure is a routine requirement. Properly disclosed and verified AI use shall not, by itself, be a reason for rejection, and manuscripts shall be judged on their scientific quality, integrity, and transparency (read more AI guideline)
AI and Authorship
AI systems and AI-assisted technologies, including large language models, chatbots, and image generators, shall not be listed as authors or co-authors, or cited as authors, because they cannot take responsibility for the work. All listed authors remain fully responsible for the accuracy, integrity, originality, and validity of the manuscript, including any content produced with AI assistance.
What Must Be Disclosed
Authors shall disclose the use of generative AI to draft, substantially edit, rewrite, summarise, or translate any part of the manuscript. Disclosure is also required where AI supported literature searching, data analysis, coding, or the creation of figures and other visual material. Disclosure is not required where tools were used only to correct spelling, grammar, or punctuation, or for basic proofreading that does not alter the content.
Where AI forms part of the research design or methods, such as AI-assisted image analysis or predictive modelling, its use shall be described in the Methods section in a reproducible manner. The description shall include the tool name, version, and manufacturer, and it is separate from the declaration of AI use in the writing process.
Content and Placement of the Declaration
Authors shall include a “Declaration of AI Use” in the main text, immediately before the References. The declaration shall be anonymised, like the rest of the main text. It shall state the name and version of each tool, the purpose of use, the nature and extent of its contribution, and the sections of the manuscript affected.
Authors shall also complete the “Use of AI tools” statement in the cover letter. Authors who did not use AI shall say so in the cover letter, and the declaration section may then be omitted from the manuscript. The declaration shall be published with the article.
Verification and Accountability
Authors shall critically review and verify all AI-assisted content before submission. They shall correct any inaccuracies, omissions, fabricated information, unsupported claims, and potentially biased content. All references shall be checked against the original sources, and AI-generated citations shall not be accepted unless independently verified.
Originality, Copyright, and Tool Terms
Authors shall ensure that AI-assisted content does not infringe copyright or reproduce material without attribution. They shall not use any AI tool whose terms restrict their own, BHJ’s, or any third party’s right to use, publish, or reproduce the submission. Authors shall also check that the tool’s terms allow the content they enter to be used only to provide the requested service.
Confidentiality and Patient Data
Authors shall not enter identifiable patient information, confidential data, or material covered by ethical approval conditions into public AI tools. Any AI use involving research data shall be consistent with the approved ethical protocol and the consent given by participants.
Images and Figures
AI-generated or AI-altered clinical images, photographs, micrographs, and figures or graphs that present research data shall not be submitted. Conceptual or explanatory diagrams may be AI-assisted if the tool’s terms permit publication and the author holds the necessary rights. Such use shall be disclosed in the figure caption and in the declaration.
Where non-generative tools were used to enhance or combine existing images, this shall be disclosed in the caption, and authors may be asked to provide the original, unaltered images. Images in articles about AI itself may be considered case by case.
AI Use Log and Evidence
Authors are encouraged to keep a record of their AI use, noting the tool, version, date, purpose, and affected sections. Authors shall provide evidence of AI use to the editors on request.
Verification and Handling of Concerns
The BHJ Secretariat shall check that the declarations in the cover letter and the manuscript are consistent and complete. Results from AI-detection or similarity software shall not, by themselves, be a basis for rejection or for an allegation of misconduct, although they may prompt a query to the authors.
Failure to disclose AI use, fabricated references or data, falsified research content, deceptive image manipulation, or other serious breaches may lead to a request for clarification, rejection, correction or retraction of published material, notification of the authors’ institution, or other appropriate action. The journal shall assess each case on its merits and follow a fair, documented procedure consistent with COPE guidance.
Peer Reviewers and Editors
Reviewers and editors shall not upload manuscripts, or any part of them, into public generative AI tools, and shall not delegate their evaluation or decision to AI. Reviewers remain accountable for the accuracy and views expressed in their reports.
Template Declaration for Authors
The declaration in the manuscript should read: “During the preparation of this work, the authors used [tool name, version] in order to [purpose] in the [section(s) affected]. After using this tool, the authors reviewed and edited the content as needed and take full responsibility for the content of the publication.”
Authors who did not use AI should state in the cover letter: “No generative AI tools were used in the preparation of this manuscript.”
